India's jobless rate has halved to 3.2%, but job quality is the open question
An analysis argues that falling unemployment figures hide underpaid, insecure work, and that jobs without contracts, insurance and dignity should not count as real progress.

India's unemployment rate has dropped from 6.1 per cent in 2017-18 to 3.2 per cent in 2023-24, according to figures cited in a new opinion analysis. The piece argues that the headline number says little about whether those jobs are any good.
The author's central point is that being employed and being securely employed are different things. Someone doing underpaid or unsatisfying work is counted as having a job, yet the analysis calls this another face of unemployment, usually called underemployment.
The pressure on government jobs shows the problem. Universities and colleges in every state turn out graduates and postgraduates in large numbers, while a notification for a hundred posts can draw lakhs of applicants. In that market, almost any other job that comes along is a compromise.
The analysis also points to a shift in rural India. Some children of families who own substantial farmland are taking lower-tier government jobs in town, in some cases earning less than the workers their families employ. The author says the pull of urban life keeps them from modernising their own farms, which could raise profits and create work for others. A smaller number of farmers are adopting modern equipment, and that is beginning to change rural labour demand.
The government's data also shows a significant rise in women workers over the past decade. The author welcomes that but asks what kind of work these women are doing and under what conditions. The piece says women in the workforce often lack job security and status, and it calls for childcare facilities, transport for those in flexible arrangements, and skills training. It also warns against paying women less to cut costs.
The yardstick it proposes is the International Labour Organization's definition of decent work: fair wages, workplace rights, social security and dignity. By that measure, the author says, a job should count only if it comes with a contract, insurance cover and social benefits. The Periodic Labour Force Survey shows some improvement in agriculture, manufacturing, construction, trade and transport, but the author says progress is uneven across sectors and still falls short.
The people most exposed are the self-employed, farmers and daily-wage workers without formal contracts. The analysis says they need protection that works in practice, not just on paper. The takeaway is that job creation and social security have to move together, or a falling jobless rate will keep hiding insecure work.
Read the full analysis at The Hans India.